This post was written by Charles F. Morgan ("Frank"), an intellectual property lawyer who represents individuals and businesses in the entertainment world. Copyright law in the music industry has some peculiar twists and Frank knows all about them.
The readers of charmcitylegal.com have a lot of questions about how to license music and lyrics for use in their own creative work, so we asked Frank to walk us through it.
Frank uses a book trailer as an example, but the clearance process applies in other situations, too, like using music as background for tutorials or training videos, or even using lyrics in your story.
Thanks, Frank. Take it away . . .
You have almost finished your first full-length novel and are turning your attention to marketing it. The idea of creating a “book trailer” that you could post on YouTube and Vimeo and use in online social media is popular in the indie publishing world. Video is the content king these days, after all. There are many articles on how to create a trailer using royalty-free music, but few consider how to license popular music for use in a trailer.
Your novel is about a young woman who has graduated from high school but is still living with her parents while holding down a job as a waitress. She works during the day and parties at night. Her parents are dismayed that their daughter seems completely satisfied with her lifestyle. There is a dark side however to their daughter’s hedonistic pursuits about which her parents are unaware.
It occurs to you that the perfect music for your book trailer would be Cyndi Lauper’s recording of “Girls Just Want to Have Fun.” You know from being a writer that copyright law protects original works of authorship, but you’re not sure how that translates into using Ms. Lauper’s song in your book trailer. You decide to consult an entertainment lawyer for advice.
Your lawyer explains that there are two copyrights in a recorded song: first, the copyright in the musical composition which includes the lyrics and melody, and second, the copyright in the sound recording.
In order to use Cyndi Lauper’s recorded version of “Girls Just Want to Have Fun,” you will need permission from the songwriters (who usually will have turned over their rights in the song to a publishing company) and permission from the record company that owns the rights to Cyndi Lauper’s recording of the song.
Neither party is required to grant permission. It is up to you to convince them to grant you the rights on terms that are acceptable to both of you.
Clearing the Music & the Lyrics
Obtaining the permissions needed to use Cyndi Lauper’s recording is called “clearing” the music for your book trailer. A grant of rights from the music publisher is called a“synchronization” or “sync” license. The right to use a particular recording of a song comes from the recording company and is called a “master use license.”
Locating the rights holders may be difficult and negotiating deals with each of them for realistic licensing fees is likely to be a challenge, but you decide to give it a try. After all, the trailer is only going to be 30 seconds long.
The place to start to find out the names of the songwriter(s) and their publishing company or companies is usually BMI, ASCAP or SESAC. These are all performing rights organizations, and they cannot grant a sync or master use license, but they often have music publishing information available in their online databases.
ASCAP’s “ACE Repertory” shows that “Girls Just Want to Have Fun” was composed by Robert Hazard, and that the music publisher is Sony/ATV Tunes LLC in Nashville. To find that a song was composed by a single songwriter with a single publisher is fortunate and somewhat unusual.
It is not uncommon for the ASCAP, BMI or SESAC databases to show that a song was written by several composers all affiliated with different music publishing companies. Sync licenses would have to be negotiated with each of them.
The next step is to contact Sony publishing and make a request for use of the song in your trailer on a form that the publisher usually provides. It is important to make a professional approach, using letterhead for example and to be specific about how the song will be used.
Give Details to Build Your Credibility
The publisher gets lots of requests for sync licenses, and in order to maintain the value of each song, the company must be careful about granting any licenses. Since you are not known to Sony publishing, they will want information with which they can evaluate the credibility of your project.
They will ask how much of the song will be used, what will be on-screen while the song is being played and the nature of the novel -- particularly the dark side of the daughter’s nightlife with which they may not want their song associated.
You should be open in your responses. You you do not want to be granted a license and then have the publishing company find that the song is being used in a way not contemplated by the license. After you submit your request, the publisher will respond usually in 30 to 90 days, with a quote and proposed deal points. Then you can either continue to negotiate the terms of a license yourself or turn it over to your lawyer to finalize the agreement.
While you are in touch with Sony publishing, you also want to negotiate with the record company that owns the rights to Cyndi Lauper’s version of “Girls Just Want to Have Fun.” She released her first solo album “She’s So Unusual” on the Portrait label in 1983. The album featured several hits including “Girls Just Want to Have Fun.” Portrait dissolved in 2002, and “She’s So Unusual” was re-released on its 30th anniversary in 2014, on the Sony Legacy label. Sony Legacy is a division of Sony Music which licenses the master recording rights it controls.
Sony Music will also want information about how the song will be used, who wants the license, the nature of the novel and other facts about the trailer. Again, they do not have to grant a license and will be protective of the property that they own.
If things don’t go smoothly, there are other options. You could engage a song writer/artist to compose and record an original 30-second track that you could use on the trailer. You could use public domain music. There are online companies that make pre-cleared music available and other sites where stock music can be licensed for free. There are also other online companies that will make a book trailer for you including the music.
Whatever option you eventually select, you should never lose sight of the fact that you cannot use someone else’s copyrighted music in your trailer without their permission.
A key take away here is that it can take up to 90 days to get a response to a request for a license. Be sure to plan ahead so you don't delay your book marketing schedule.
Have you ever tried to license music for one of your creative projects? Tell us how it went in the comments. If you have a question about licensing music, ask below.
You can reach Frank at firstname.lastname@example.org.
What about using a phrase from a song lyric in a visual work or collage?
Excellent question, Monica. I think using a song lyric in a visual work or collage could be transformative and constitute fair use. If the lyric is the “heart and soul” of the work of visual, it’s less likely to be transformative.
Have you ever tried to license music for one of your creative projects? Tell us how it went in the comments. I was semi-successful. I requested permission to use Irving Berlin’s “Always”. They offered licensing of 500 units for $75. Seemed reasonable except I wanted to release as an eBook. It has been five months and a few emails and no response. Anyone been successful with eBook licensing?
Far less successful attempting to include 20-30 second sound snippets from 50s and 60s songs. Orchestrating that is painful, and may be prohibitively expensive. I thought it would be a win-win. I use a hyperlink of their song to drive listeners to point of sale. Not working that way. Oh well. This should be easier.
If you are having difficulty clearing music for your projects, you might consider retaining a music clearance house to do it for you. The good ones typically have connections with the publishing companies and record labels and sometimes can get you the best price in the shortest period of time. They charge a fee, but it may be worth it to you to avoid the hassle and uncertainty of trying to clear the music yourself.
Hello! I recently released my book on amazon and found the perfect music for my story’s trailer. I already used it after which the issue of copyright came to my mind. Now I have no idea how to go about it. I am an Indian and the music that I have chosen is definitely not from around here.
I am working on a college project and would love to use one of Cyndi Lauper’s songs; I have narrowed it down to two options. As I do not have disposable income, I am hoping to gain legal permission to do so.
My vision is to bring attention to a great number of stereotypes, misconceptions and atrocities that are aimed, mostly, at those that have struggled with discrimination, violence and hatred for years.
Any assistance in my endeavor would be much appreciated and truly be a blessing and dream come true, for me.