In a rare victory over forced arbitration of consumer claims, on February 19, 2010, the Court of Appeals of Maryland dismissed an appeal by Case Handyman and Remodeling Services in a class action lawsuit filed against Case by Thomas J. Minton and Goldman & Minton, P.C. on behalf of two Baltimore County homeowners, Judith and Albert Schuele. The Schueles allege that Case, a national franchisor of home improvement companies, is liable for approximately $40,000 in damages they suffered when a Case franchisee, Professional Home Repair, Inc. (“PHR”) took a deposit from them on a substantial home improvement project and failed to do any work.